Fake Lamps or not?

[Giarrese]

Good evening, I purchased these lamps on Catawiki. I would like help. Are they real or fake? Tank you very much for helping me.

[gaius asinius]

Hopefully someone provides insight. Most antiquities on Catawiki run the gamut between questionable and laughable.

[Jerry F]

This question is in the wrong section.
Anyway.....

The first lamp I'm unsure about.
The second is a genuine one , Diana with her bow, which is the basis of a well known fake.See photo.

Lots of very useful information about fake lamps here:

https://www.collector-antiquities.com/real-or-fake/fake-oil-lamps.html

I have taken the image here from that great website.

Jerry

[Giarrese]

Thanks for the reply and sorry if I posted in the wrong section (which is the correct one?)
You said: "The first lamp I'm unsure about" but what if you have to give a definitive opinion? The subject represented is a satyr playing a musical instrument. I attach a lamp where the subject is clearer. Thanks again

[Jerry F]

Hello again,
Yes, this one is genuine too. Probably 2nd-3rd century.
I see you posted these questions to the io group also.
If you can get an opinion there from David K that would be great as he is as knowlegeable about ancient oil lamps as anyone can be!
Jerry

[Giarrese]

Thanks jerry. You were really very kind. I hope Dave answers me.

[Giarrese]

Hello again,
Yes, this one is genuine too. Probably 2nd-3rd century.
I see you posted these questions to the io group also.
If you can get an opinion there from David K that would be great as he is as knowlegeable about ancient oil lamps as anyone can be!
Jerry

Dear jerry I got a reply from David K as you can see  here https://groups.io/g/AncientArtifacts. He has no doubts about the authenticity of the lamps. Tank you for all.